Le Pen's financial blueprint in France: consolidation efforts are sufficient, but the trajectory is overly optimistic.
The French National Rally (RN) is gradually outlining a comprehensive fiscal consolidation plan. The recently introduced "shadow budget," medium-term fiscal plan, and fiscal "golden rule" address France's deteriorating fiscal situation from three perspectives: short-term budget, medium-term debt, and institutional constraints.
According to a report released by Goldman Sachs on October 7, the fiscal consolidation proposed by the Reserve Bank of New York (RN) is not weak. Its "shadow budget" plans to improve the main fiscal deficit by about 2 percentage points within a year, and in the medium term, it hopes to achieve a main fiscal surplus of 1.2% of GDP by 2032. However, the problem lies in the fact that this plan makes relatively optimistic assumptions about economic growth, spending austerity, and the speed of policy implementation.
Goldman Sachs' poll-based model indicates that Marine Le Pen is the frontrunner in next year's French presidential election, and the ROK is also expected to win a majority of seats in the National Assembly. If this political scenario materializes, the ROK's fiscal plan will no longer be just a campaign promise, but could directly impact France's fiscal policy and debt trajectory for years to come.
For the market, the real concern is not whether the Reserve Bank of France (RN) has proposed sufficiently aggressive fiscal consolidation, but whether these adjustments can be implemented as planned. Goldman Sachs predicts that France's economic growth will be only 0.6% in 2027, and its public debt ratio may reach 125% in 2032, significantly deviating from the RN's planned downward path. The trade-off between fiscal consolidation and economic growth, and the debt risks following the failure of optimistic assumptions, will be important variables for French government bonds and Eurozone assets.
"Shadow Budget": Aggressive consolidation measures, but unlikely to be fully implemented in the short term.
The RND's "shadow budget" plan aims to improve France's main fiscal deficit from -2.6% of GDP in 2027 to -0.6%, an adjustment of about 2 percentage points, and will be achieved almost entirely by cutting public spending, while the revenue side will remain basically unchanged.
However, this goal faces realistic constraints in terms of timeline. The French parliamentary elections are not until July of next year at the earliest, and even if the RN wins a majority of seats, the time available to actually implement related measures will be very limited. Furthermore, according to standard fiscal multiplier estimates, such fiscal austerity could drag down economic growth by about 0.5 to 1 percentage point; weaker-than-expected economic growth would, in turn, weaken the extent of fiscal improvement.
Another significant aspect of this plan is that it may reveal the RN's policy bottom line in budget negotiations. For example, the RN advocates for pensions to be fully linked to inflation, rather than partially linked as in the government's plan. This adjustment itself could increase fiscal spending by approximately 0.2% of GDP.
Therefore, Goldman Sachs expects France's fiscal deficit to reach 5.3% in 2027, higher than the government's previous target of 5.0%, mainly due to weak economic growth expectations and upward pressure on some spending items.
Medium-term plan: Scope of spending cuts expanded, but the debt reduction path is optimistic.
The RN's medium-term fiscal plan proposes to increase the main fiscal deficit to 1.2% of GDP by 2032 and to push the public debt ratio into a downward trend.
Goldman Sachs believes this framework is broadly consistent with the assessment that France needs to maintain a major fiscal surplus of over 1% of GDP in the long term, but the RN's forecast of economic growth reaching 1.8% between 2028 and 2030 is significantly more optimistic. At the same time, the plan requires the major fiscal deficit to improve by about 1.5 percentage points during this period, but fails to propose sufficiently large-scale structural reforms to support it.
The spending cuts outlined by the RN are more comprehensive than before, including reducing the size of the civil service, streamlining healthcare spending, cutting housing subsidies, and reducing local government spending. However, Goldman Sachs believes that the plan's estimates for cutting immigration spending, combating tax and welfare fraud, and reducing contributions to EU transfers may be too high.
Some of these measures also face institutional obstacles: some policies may be restricted by the French Constitution, and adjustments to EU transfer payments cannot be decided unilaterally by France.
The "Golden Rule": Strengthening fiscal discipline, but the exception mechanism remains questionable.
Le Bon's "golden rule" for fiscal policy attempts to lock in the path of fiscal consolidation from an institutional perspective: when the debt ratio is higher than 60%, the government must improve the fiscal deficit by 0.5 percentage points each year until the fiscal deficit reaches 0.5 percentage points above the debt stability level.
The rule is proposed to be enshrined in the constitution through a national referendum, and the French High Council for Public Finance will be responsible for estimating the fiscal level required for debt stability. The National Assembly can suspend the rule for two consecutive years by a three-fifths majority, and whether to continue the suspension thereafter will be decided by a referendum.
Goldman Sachs believes that placing fiscal rules within the framework of the constitution and independent fiscal institutions would help strengthen fiscal discipline, but the design itself remains controversial. Using the total fiscal deficit rather than the main fiscal deficit as an anchor indicator would further increase the pressure on fiscal adjustments during periods of rising interest payments; meanwhile, debt sustainability typically does not require the debt ratio to strictly return to 60%, but rather focuses on whether the medium-term debt ratio can stabilize.
More notably, the lack of established international precedent for allowing the extension of fiscal rules through referendums may make it difficult for markets to assess the strength of the constraints that such rules can provide during periods of stress.
The key is not the strength of the consolidation, but whether it can be fulfilled.
The RN's three-pronged approach has formed a relatively complete fiscal framework: short-term spending cuts, medium-term achievement of major fiscal surpluses, and strengthened constraints through constitutional fiscal rules. Compared to past fiscal proposals that leaned more towards political slogans, this approach has improved in both its digitalization and policy coverage.
However, Goldman Sachs' core criticism is also very clear: RN's fiscal consolidation goals are not incomprehensible in themselves; the real problem is the growth and austerity assumptions upon which achieving these goals depends.
If economic growth fails to meet expectations, or if actual savings in areas such as immigration and welfare fraud fall short of plans, fiscal improvement may be slower than expected, and the debt ratio may be difficult to decline along the RN's path.
Therefore, for the French government bond market, the biggest risk after the ROK takes office may not necessarily come from "insufficient fiscal consolidation," but rather from excessive consolidation leading to short-term growth pressure, while the reduction in medium- and long-term debt fails to materialize . If both occur simultaneously, the risk premium for French government bonds may still face upward pressure.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
The above content is from Zhuifeng Trading Platform .
For more detailed analysis, including real-time updates and firsthand research, please join the [ Trading Channel Annual Membership ].

Risk warning and disclaimerInvesting involves risk; please exercise caution. This article does not constitute personal investment advice and does not take into account the specific investment objectives, financial situation, or needs of individual users. Users should consider whether any opinions, views, or conclusions in this article are suitable for their specific circumstances. Any investment decisions made based on this information are at your own risk.