Trump can no longer draw crude oil candlestick charts.

Trump can no longer draw crude oil candlestick charts.

The oil market's sensitivity to Trump's rhetoric is systematically diminishing. A tweet threatening Iran that once sent oil prices soaring by 7% in a single day now elicits almost no reaction. According to Bloomberg's analysis of price movements, as the US-Iran conflict continues to drag on, the influence of Trump's statements on the global oil market has significantly weakened.

On April 1st of this year, Trump threatened in a televised address to strike Iran, sending it "back to the Stone Age." Oil prices immediately surged in early Asian trading, ultimately closing up over 7%, breaking through $109 per barrel. However, on October 1st, Trump again warned Iran to "sign a ceasefire agreement or cease to exist," yet oil prices remained almost unmoved. The same threatening language elicited drastically different market reactions.

According to a Bloomberg report on October 8, oil traders interviewed said they are no longer focusing on the White House's rhetoric, but rather on hard data such as changes in physical supply and freight flows. At the same time, given the high unpredictability of US war strategy, traders are also proactively reducing their positions. This shift will not only affect the energy market but will also further obscure the inflation outlook and have a ripple effect on global interest rate policy.

From "Instant Response" to "Desensitization": Seven Months of Trust Depletion

In the early stages of the Iran war, every word Trump uttered sent shivers down the spines of oil traders. The specter of a Strait of Hormuz blockade lingered in the market, repeatedly priced in as the worst-case scenario. As this nightmare partially materialized—shipping through the waterway nearly ground to a halt—the global energy market suffered a severe shock.

However, in the seven months that followed, Trump repeatedly hinted at progress in US-Iran diplomatic negotiations or that an agreement was imminent, only to quickly reverse course; he also proposed a transit fee for the Strait of Hormuz, which he abandoned in less than a day. These erratic policy signals led traders to gradually view his pronouncements as unreliable price guidance.

“For months, the headlines have been spinning like a revolving door,” said John Kilduff, a partner at Again Capital. “Trading in this market right now is basically playing geopolitical roulette. Everyone I’ve spoken to is downsizing their trades.”

Rob Thummel, senior portfolio manager at Tortoise Capital Advisors LLC, also pointed out:

"The White House's wavering statements have paralyzed traders."

Price volatility narrows, liquidity crisis looms.

As traders stepped back to the sidelines, the intraday volatility of crude oil prices also contracted. According to Bloomberg's analysis of intraday price movements, the daily high-low spread is now far smaller than at the beginning of the war, and reduced attacks on energy infrastructure have further suppressed market volatility.

Even more alarming is the liquidity crisis. Open interest in Brent crude oil futures contracts has fallen to its lowest level since March 2025. This shrinking market depth means that prices could face even more volatile and irrational fluctuations should unforeseen events occur.

When rhetoric-driven volatility subsides, markets sometimes become hunting grounds for algorithmic trading. Algorithmic traders, such as Commodity Trading Advisors (CTAs), primarily use momentum tracking strategies, often amplifying price fluctuations in two-way markets. Although such volatility usually returns to normal before the end of the trading day, the process can create a significant divergence between the physical and paper markets, further pushing traditional investors out of the market.

Supply data replaces presidential tweets as the new anchor

As Trump's rhetoric loses its pricing power, physical supply indicators are filling the void. Traders are turning their attention to hard indicators that can be tracked in real time and are directly actionable, such as freight flows and pipeline data.

Michael O'Rourke, chief market strategist at JonesTrading Institutional Services LLC, said:

"The president has said a lot, and his stance has changed quite frequently. After several rounds of headline-driven impact, the market does indeed become desensitized, and now everyone is clearly more focused on physical flow data because it is real-time and actionable."

Even analysts admit that it's increasingly difficult to develop effective models for the course of war. A recent research report from JPMorgan Chase analysts stated:

" We simply didn't know how to model the outcome. In the early stages of the war, we thought we did. "

The spillover effects of energy shocks have far-reaching macroeconomic implications.

The current conflict with Iran has triggered the most severe oil supply shock in history. Coupled with Ukraine's continued attacks on Russian refining facilities, retail fuel prices in many parts of the world have risen to historic highs. Central bank officials in Europe and other regions have expressed concern about the persistent inflation caused by soaring energy costs, and oil price trends have become deeply embedded in the pricing logic of bond and stock markets.

Domestically in the United States, soaring energy prices are putting political pressure on Trump's Republican Party, casting a shadow over the prospects for the November midterm elections.

Decreased visibility in the crude oil market will directly obscure the global inflation path, thereby affecting the interest rate decision-making space of central banks around the world. When one of the most important price signals in the market becomes chaotic, its spillover effects will extend far beyond the energy sector itself.

Nevertheless, most traders acknowledge that Trump's statements cannot be completely ignored—he is ultimately the final decision-maker regarding military deployments and the course of the war with Iran. However, until clearer signals emerge from outside the White House, most speculators are choosing to remain on the sidelines, awaiting direction from physical supply data.

Risk warning and disclaimerInvesting involves risk; please exercise caution. This article does not constitute personal investment advice and does not take into account the specific investment objectives, financial situation, or needs of individual users. Users should consider whether any opinions, views, or conclusions in this article are suitable for their specific circumstances. Any investment decisions made based on this information are at your own risk.